Team & training

How do I run fair performance reviews?

By Oshry Labs · Updated 16 November 2026

Why it happens

Reviews done in emails and spreadsheets differ by manager. One is generous, one is strict, and nobody can compare people across teams.

When reviews aren't recorded, progress is invisible and decisions about promotion rely on memory.

How to fix it, step by step

  1. Write criteria per role

    Four to eight things that matter in that role, with what good looks like.

  2. Use one scale

    The same rating scale for everyone, with a short description of each point.

  3. Gather more than one view

    360 feedback from managers, peers and team members where it fits.

  4. Compare on a nine-box grid

    Performance and potential side by side to plan development.

  5. Schedule and record

    Regular reviews, reminders to managers, and every review kept.

Free things you can do this week

  • Write the criteria for one role this week.
  • Agree with managers what each rating means.
  • Book the next review dates now.

How we solve it

We've built a talent management system and employee performance review software for a national auto parts retailer, including nine-box grids and 360 reviews. People & Performance, the ready-made version, is coming soon; custom builds are available now.

Coming soonPeople & PerformanceSee who's performing and who's ready to grow.Join the waitlist

Want this sorted for your business? Book a free 30-minute chat with our chief engineer by phone call, Zoom or Google Meet.

Book a chat

Proof from real work

Client names are kept confidential. Only what was actually built is listed.

A national auto parts retailer

Talent management system, online training academy and employee performance review software.

Read the case study

Frequently asked questions

What is a nine-box grid?

A three-by-three grid that places each person by current performance and future potential, used to plan development and succession.

What is a 360 review?

A review that gathers feedback from several directions: a person's manager, peers and the people they lead.

How often should I review staff?

At least once a year, with shorter check-ins in between. Many businesses review twice a year.