Choosing software

Should I buy off-the-shelf software or get custom software built?

By Oshry Labs · Updated 16 November 2026

Why it happens

Off-the-shelf software is cheap to start and quick to set up, but it's built for the average business. When yours isn't average, the gaps fill with workarounds.

Custom software fits exactly but costs more upfront and needs looking after. The wrong choice either way costs time and money.

How to fix it, step by step

  1. Write down your process

    From enquiry to payment, including the awkward parts.

  2. Trial two or three products

    Run a real week of work through them, not a demo.

  3. Count the workarounds

    Every spreadsheet, retyped entry or WhatsApp step the product needs.

  4. Price both properly

    Subscriptions over three years versus a fixed build plus support.

  5. Consider the middle

    A ready-made product customised, or existing tools connected.

Free things you can do this week

  • List every app you pay for and what each one does.
  • Note where staff retype information between them.
  • Ask your team which tool they'd keep if they could only keep one.

How we solve it

We'll tell you honestly when off-the-shelf is the right answer. Our ready-made products cover common needs, and custom projects often start from one of them, which makes them faster and cheaper.

Want this sorted for your business? Book a free 30-minute chat with our chief engineer by phone call, Zoom or Google Meet.

Book a chat

Proof from real work

Client names are kept confidential. Only what was actually built is listed.

The Carpet Guys

Our chief engineer's own service business: job scheduling, quoting, invoicing and rug tracking.

Read the case study

P.A.R.T.S

Rug tracking software built for The Carpet Guys, now used by other rug cleaning plants, including WoolSafe Approved Service Providers in South Africa.

Read the case study

Frequently asked questions

Is custom software worth it for a small business?

When your process is what sets you apart, or when you're paying for several apps plus workarounds, it often is. Otherwise, start with off-the-shelf.

Can I customise off-the-shelf software?

Some products can be configured or extended. Our own products can have custom work built on top.

What's the risk with custom software?

Cost overruns and a system nobody maintains. A fixed quote and a support retainer remove both.